Cloudreloaded Vs. H2o

Losers Bracket

Renders will be judged on:

Difficulty
Uniquness - How unique the render is (has it been done before)
Usability - IS A MAJOR FACTOR!!
How Well The Image Has Been Cut
Size - NOTE This Is Not A Major Factor.

CloudReloaded:

Original:

http://ho5t.us/uploads/06839e5e09.jpg

Render:



H2o:

Original:

http://www.sinsnipers.com/images/renders/wlvrne_38_1280.jpg

Render:

 

I've already PM'ed you.

 

Clouds render is currently not working.

 

Fixed.

 

Cloudreloaded's original image isn't working for me now.

 

shoud work now
http://ho5t.us/uploads/0bdb19e0a7.jpg

i know i lost already lol

 

Yup cloud, you did lol.

Okay Cloud Reloaded-

Size: Big enough. 8/10
Cut: A FEW missed spots. Nothing major at all. Just things I would touch up on. 8/10
Difficulty - NOTHING advanced at all... 2/10
Usability - It's slightly useable, I don't know many people that will use a render like that. It'll go well in large graphics. 4/10.

Overall: 4.2/10

h2o

Size: Huge 9/10
Cut: Perfect cut, I see NOTHING wrong with it. 10/10
Difficulty: Nothing extremely difficult, just time consuming. 8/10
Usability: I've seen this used MANY times. I know it's very useable. 9/10
Overall: 9/10

Winner: h2o.

To me, this is no contest. Cloud just threw a render in just to not be disqualified.

 

I'm gonna do this quick again too, cuz it isn't fair against the others if i don't.


CloudReloaded

pretty easy looking picture, (original isn't showing). the hair doesn't looks too great, there is still some different color at the edges. The rest looks pretty decent, apart from some outlining.



H2o

seems a lot more difficult then CR's picture. I don't see mutch wrong with it, apart from the glows, hair and needles on a white background, that just looks ugly.



My vote goes to H2o, his render looks more usable and looks more difficult. both have decent size.

 

honestly i didnt know i was still in the battle i thought it was over when i lost in the winners round, then i got a pm saying im still in from the loser brackets so yea, i wasnt prepared and didnt really care for roty anymore cause i cant find any good pic to render

rendermods should lock this i lost

 

CLOUDRELOADED
Difficulty 6/10 - Doesn't look too difficult to render.
Uniquness - 7/10 I've seen this a couple of times
Usability - 6/10 Useable in some signatures, but that's really all.
Cut - 5/10 The hair looks choppy and there is some outline left on some of the edges
Size - 8/10 It's a nicely sized render

H2O
Difficulty 9/10 - This looks like a very difficult cut to make. Not many smooth surfaces on the image.
Uniquness - 7/10 I've seen this one a couple of times as well
Usability - 9/10 - Very useable. Signatures, and even some wallpapers as well
Cut - 10/10 - Absolutely flawless
Size - 9/10 This is a nice big render


My vote goes to- H2O

 

CloudReloaded

Difficulty only hard part I see is the hair
Uniquness - How unique the render is (has it been done before) I am not sure I have seen it
Usability - IS A MAJOR FACTOR!! useability is ok, maybe a dark grunge sig
How Well The Image Has Been Cut- really good cut
Size - NOTE This Is Not A Major Factor. good size

h20

Difficulty- that looks fairly hard with all the little stuff in there
Uniquness - How unique the render is (has it been done before) um lets just say this........... 0.00000000001/10
Usability - IS A MAJOR FACTOR!! Very useabl e 9.5/10 everything but vector
How Well The Image Has Been Cut great especially with the details
Size - NOTE This Is Not A Major Factor. great size

GMV to h2o, it looks just like cloudreloaded threw a render out and he just didn't want to be disqualified

 

If you want me to vote, the render of Cloudreloaded has to be reuploaded on a different host. Somehow my comp can't display images uploaded on ho5t.us (neither firefox or internet explorer). Cant see the original either.

 

Cloudreloaded

Difficulty :7/10 no really hard
Uniquness :haven´t seen it before 10/10
Usability :i don´t like the image and can´t see it in a good sig only in a grunge 7.5/10
How Well The Image Has Been Cut : good cut some problems in the hair 8/10
Size : big 8/10

H20

Difficulty : very hard the needles overal 9/10
Uniquness : i have seen it before one a couple of times 8/10
Usability : High i have seen it be used many times 9/10
How Well The Image Has Been Cut : awesome cut 9.5/10
Size : nice 9/10

Gmv H2o

 

Nice renders

CloudReloaded:

Difficulty: Easy, 4/10 at this point of the contest i think you should have tryed to do something harder, "looks like you only rendered this to not be desquilified"

Uniquness: Never saw this before, not even on a sig 10/10!

Usability: Eh, not so usable, maybe in really dark sigs or in some type of hard smudge :huh: 4/10

How Well The Image Has Been Cut: Good cut, 8/10. Yet again not so hard

Size: OK size, just a bit small im my judgin'

Last looks: A good render, but it doesnt seem that it took you so long ^^ Maybe you did work hard on it, but you probably didnt have the time to make something better, beacause it looks like you render waaay better than this ^_^
---------------------------------------------------------

Next, H2o :

Difficulty: Frustrating, to say the least Theres much detail on it, so its probably a hard cut, 8/10

Uniquness: Saw this, like 10000000 times before, still it hasnt been seen in quite a while. Uniquness: 2/10

Usability: VERY USABLE. This can be used in almost evrything! Except grunge, Usability: 7/10

How Well The Image Has Been Cut: Good cut, cane see any flaws on it ATM, 8/10 ^_^ ( i only looked at it for like 30 secs)

Size: Big, good size makes it usable on sigs

Last lookz: cool render, very usable. only thing its been done tons so not soemthing new, missed the uniquness factor :wub:

Not really hard decision, CloudReloaded himself knows hw could have done better with some more time on it. not exactly a hard chioce, sorry

H2O GMV B)

 

6-0 H2O