Good, but there’s an error in the 1st one and they both look like the same old tried and tested – nothing new, original or refreshing (IMO) so, 6/10 from me.
top one i dont like. too empty. not bad though. 7/10 bottom one is better. better brushing. nice render and blending. text is nice. 9/10
First sig is awesome and I like that nice blood effect 9/10 Second's plain, but render made it hawt. WOW 9.9999/10
Kinda plain... color wise. But overall nice outcome, nice brushing. Nice scratches too... Render couldve been blended better. Text (both main and quote needs more work) and make them stand out. Change the damn border. Me no likey... 7.4/10