gonna have to go with forgotten. Nice colouring and the render looks creepy. Arthas if you had better text/font you'd have had my vote.
I'm going to go with Forgotten's on this one because of the nice brushing and the render, as for Arthas' sig, it would be better if you made the text more visible, probably a 1 pix stroke with higher opacity would help Arthas: 0 Fxsoul: 4