Psychospike Vs Shneakysquirrel

Losers Bracket

Renders will be judged on:

Difficulty
Uniquness - How unique the render is (has it been done before)
Usability - IS A MAJOR FACTOR!!
How Well The Image Has Been Cut
Size - NOTE This Is Not A Major Factor.

PsychoSpike:

Original:

http://img71.imageshack.us/img71/6209/guil...ighresmonk1.jpg

Render:



ShneakySquirrel:

Original:

http://img33.imageshack.us/img33/5103/warh...chaos0013gy.jpg

Render:

 

aww shneaky no original :[..
Pychospike, woah, awsome render, nothing choppy absolutley perfect, though its been done a few times its a good choice and is very good i was going to vote yours but i saw shneakys... and holy crap, thats AWSOME, ive never seen it done before, and it looks uber uber hard, im not seeing ney choppiness either.
My vote goes to... Shneaky squirel

 

Woah!!!!

Psycho spike
man that is awesome!!

Difficulty- I would give the difficulty 7/10
Uniquness - How unique the render is (has it been done before). I have seen that
Usability - IS A MAJOR FACTOR!! VERY useable
How Well The Image Has Been Cut- Great, no choppyness at all
Size - NOTE This Is Not A Major Factor.good size

ShneakySquirrel
are u sure u are in the loser bracker? cuz that is the awesomeness!

Difficulty- no original but I can't tell it was hard
Uniquness - How unique the render is (has it been done before)- have not seen
Usability - IS A MAJOR FACTOR!! HARD GRUNGE
How Well The Image Has Been Cut- very clean cut
Size- great size

GMV to shneakySquirrel becuz I like the render a little more than Psychospike's and it's bigger. everything else I think is the same.

 

PsychoSpike
1st thought
- Nice and clean cut

Mistakes
- some little outlining while viewing on bright background

Positive
- Nice work on the glows
- It looks very clean. Although there is outlining, this hasn’t got a negative effect on the render.

Negative
- You rendered only half the picture and duplicated it to make a whole character. At first I thought you used a different picture, but I searched for the complete version, and there were differences between left and right, so it hit me, that you duplicated the whole thing. Smart move, and it will only have a slight negative effect on my judgement.


ShneakySquirrel
1st thought
- Nice details

Note
- Why didn’t you posted original? It’s not that you don’t have it, cuz you posted it before. Also the website isn’t copyrighted and the wallpaper doesn’t request a membership in order to be downloaded.

Mistakes
- There is outlining on some parts of the picture

Positive
- Nice size and pretty difficult

Negative
- I don’t like the picture
- Original is from a plain dark background, and the picture isn’t that bright itself, that makes it hard to create a bad cut, since outlining won’t be visible. This also has a positive side, dark pictures on dark backgrounds are pretty difficult to cut.


My vote would go to PsychoSpike. It was a difficult choice, I had to compete difficulty with usability. Shneaky’s is way more difficult, but I don’t like the picture, and I don’t see much use in it. The colours are too messy to make a nice sig with it. Psycho’s however isn’t that difficult, but it would look nice in sigs. Since usability is a major factor, I voted for Psycho.

if you want a better explanation containing pictures, please pm me, and add link to original picture, render and my own comment. Thank you.

- LA-384

 

thx for noticing the duplicated right side, LA, i wasn't sure to use it, but seeing that there aren't many pics you could pull this off, i did it..

i would like to see shneakys original though... <_< :lol:

 

ok well, boht these renders are really well cut, hard to say how difficult sneakys was, not phycho rewnders look real hard, there boht very uniquee, great size, and usable !!

so my vote goes to

Phsycho

 

The reason I can't post my original, is because I can only access a computer at the school computers. And at the school computers I can't access the site I got it at ( http://www.e-wallpapers.de ). If someone could get it for me, it's under Warhammer40k I believe

 

shneaky, i actually have this wallpaper on my computer which i got from e-wallpapers.de

heres your original

http://img33.imageshack.us/img33/5103/warh...chaos0013gy.jpg

 

psychospike
erm... introducing this rendered guy :lol:
it's a great render m8 i really like it very smooth around the edges. difficulty... 6/10. usable for sigs and web graphics, not suitable for larger images. keep away from children under 3. JUST KIDDING, had to say that. from time to time i post nonsense like that size is pretty decent. however since it's not THE most popular character in the world :lol: i think it wouldn't be too practical to use. anyway it's a REALLY clean cut and a FANTASTIC render! i like it!

Shneakysquirrel
that's really something! something... weird... what is that? :lol: looks like treebeard fell into a vat of chemical toxins :lol: anyway i really think that's a fantastic render! looks very difficult about 9/10. not very usable for anything but sigs, which it is FANTASTIC for but outside of that or a gaming site banner it'd look a little... too uncommon. size seems really small since it's not a closeup but it's pretty good. some of it is choppy but i think it's nice overall, great job!

my vote goes to... *drumroll*

Shneakysquirrel! Great job m8! congrats to both of you!

~nightfire

 

that's the best orginal ever!
just black

 

awsome renders greatly cut keep up the good work

 

3 - 2 To SS so far! Need more votes.

 

PsychoSpike:

Difficulty: I'd say about 7/10

Uniquness - I don't think I've seen it before though

Usability - I think this is well usable for sigs. Cut has been done well, nice round cut on the head and nice cutting with the glow from the hand.

Size - Size is okay I guess.

ShneakySquirrel:

Difficulty: I'd say about 8/10

Uniquness - I haven't seen before imo

Usability - From all the image, I think this can be used well for grunge sigs awesome cutting aroud the edges and sides

Size - Size is big and can see the image more clearly

My Vote goes to ShneakySquirrel.

 

Good Renders Guys..

Pshycospike

Difficulty - The cut looks Fairly easy, accept for those glows, which were done very well on a side note, but I see no choppy parts at all.

Unique - Another Guild Wars Render? Ive seen to many of them renders and just getting sick of them, no matter hjow good it was cut, still loses points for Uniqueness.

Usability - Extremely Useable, especialy for the sigs with lighter colors. this gewts you another point In my book for its useability.

How well the Cut Was - Simply beautifully cut, the person it self is amazing, no choppy parts at all! and those glows are amazing! this gets you another point from me!

Size - Failry, Medium size, still very useabile, and again it was a great cut, so that also gives u another point.

Shneaky

Difficulty - WOW!!! Amazing choice to render Look so hard to cut, so many curves, bumps, and bruises Looks great shneaky, Amazingly Great.

Uniqe - Ive never seen this thing ever, never! Shenaky deffinitly got a point for this uniqueness. Great Pick!

How well image was cut - BEAUTIFULL!! Simply amazing, no choopy parts at all, very smooth.

Size / Useability - HUGE!! Great size shneaky and very useable in sigs, just amazing!

After a hard desision.

My vote goes to..



SHNEAKY

Good job both of you.

~Dooks.

 

5 - 2 to SS so far!