-truimph- Vs Pyschospike

Losers bracket

Renders will be judged on:
Difficulty
How unique the render is
Usability - IS A MAJOR FACTOR!!
How Well The Image Has Been Cut
Size - NOTE This Is Not A Major Factor.

Both entrees have been recieved.

-Truimph-:

Original:

http://www.gamewallpapers.com/wallpapers.p...A+The+Third+Age

Rendered:



PyschoSpike:

Original:

http://img352.imageshack.us/img352/802/20544bb.jpg

Rendered:

 

MY BAD! im retarded, got confused when i was tired, no worries Huy-N and shneaky explained it to me, you can delete my posts ;p

 

PsychoSpike GMV. Better usability, alot more unique, and overall a great cut. Both of you, again, gj.

 

delete this please >.<

 

-triumph-
Great job on the render, but quite small indeed. Good for web graphics, especially, but not so much signatures (small graphics) or any large graphic, for that matter. Difficutly is about 6/10, not exactly an astounding undertaking. I really like the cut although it could use slight improvement around Gimli's right arm. Where did it go!? lol Great work!

Psychospike
Hey, is that Stubbs the Zombie? AHHHH! NO! He's coming to get me! That is an amazing cut, and although the difficulty seems average at around 7/10 it's WONDERFUL! Great for sigs, especially, and web banners. The size is a little too small for larger graphics, however. I really like the render overall!

My vote goes to...*drumroll*

Psychospike
Yet another great render! Great job, to both of you!

~Nightfire

 

Triumph

Difficulty- It's not too hard or easy. then again you do have the fire bg. 7.5/10
How unique the render is- well I don't think it's that unique. we have enough guys with axes.
Usability - IS A MAJOR FACTOR!! I can't see all those people being used at once. you would have to use one of them. and they're small
How Well The Image Has Been Cut- the cut is ok there is a few choppy and dodgy spots. and a little outline. but gj overall
Size - NOTE This Is Not A Major Factor. The size I think is almost too small and that can bring useability down.

PyschoSpike

Difficulty- with how you cut it it's not difficult. If you had cut the other stuff around the smoke you would have won the contest. lol. with what you have 6/10. if you had cut the other stuff. 9.5/10
How unique the render is- pretty weird. um... yeah
Usability - IS A MAJOR FACTOR!! I can see that being used in maybe a smudge or grunge
How Well The Image Has Been Cut - good cut all around. the smoke woulden't be hard. just feather it. the guy is a good cut also. then again you should of cut the other stuff around the smoke
Size - NOTE This Is Not A Major Factor. Great size for a render

GMV to PyschoSpike because the cut and size is better. and better useablility.

 

Difficulty - 6/10
How unique the render is - Unique
Usability - Low High
How Well The Image Has Been Cut - Good
Size - Good

GMV to PsychoSpike

 

Nice renders you got there. Heres how i voted:


@ -Triumph-

Ehm, not really. Im being hard on this one. The render is very choppy, and i dont really think
it would fit in a sig actually. But still, it has good potential.

The original didnt seem that hard to render from.

------------------------------------------------

@ PsychoSpike

Better render overall, but still i see some (very small) choppy parts on it. The smoke is well cloned or whatever you did to make it like that,
and the original didnt seem so hard to render from.
I think this one would fit very well in a sig aswell in a wallpaper. So this render has some great potentials ^_^

Well done.

-------------------------------------------------

So my vote goes to... PsychoSpike!

 

PyschoSpike Wins 5 - 0