Wolverine Vs Dooks

Losers Bracket

Renders will be judged on:
Difficulty
How unique the render is
Usability - IS A MAJOR FACTOR!!
How Well The Image Has Been Cut
Size - NOTE This Is Not A Major Factor.

Both entrants renders recieved.

Wolverine:

Original:

http://www.soulchamber.us/uploads/4a7324c3ae.jpg

Rendered:



Dooks:

Original:

http://images.ea.com/eagames/official/lotr..._ConceptArt.jpg

Rendered:

 

i just want to wish u luck Dooks, may the best render win

 

Wolverine GMV. Better usability, cut is a bit better, I like the picture better. Both of you GJ.

 

Err soldier, could You give at least a breif explanation? Why?

What about you JpRox?

Remember this isnt some battle in the sig area.

This is a huge contest that should be taken in all high respects.

 

I think Soldier and Jprox votes must be deleted coz they aren`t judges...

 

Wolv gmv.looks alot harder and has been cut better.The other render by dooks is really choppy.

 

My vote goes to Dooks.

Difficulty: Looks very difficult to cut.
Unique: Never seen. Wolverine's, I have seen a numerous amount of times.
Usability: Good for sigs
The Cut: Very clean cut, looks like there was a lot of effort put into it.
Size: Good size, usable for a lot of things.

 

Difficulty: Based on the originals their difficulty isn't very high. No hair and not all that many difficult shadows to deal with.

Unique: Personally, I've never seen either one before so both are equal.

Usability: Here is where it counted really. Wolverine's is very difficult to use in a signature to the render's full capabilities. You are limited to an odd angle of the render if you wish to get both Doc Oc and Spidey in the image and that's the whole point of the render. Image is too vertical for a signature. Very useful in a wallpaper but it's limited to only that. Dooks is horizontal, making it ideal for a signature.

The Cut: Dook's image has some rough edges on the back of the ship but overall a nice cut. Wolverine's image is much crisper but the render and the background contrast a lot more then Dook's, making it slightly easier to cut.

Size: Both good sizes. Equal here as well.

Final: Dook gets my vote.

 

Very nice renders both of you. Heres how i voted:


@ Wolverine

The cut itself is very good, but the text on one of the 'arms' kinda kill it. And i think it will be hard to fit the whole render in a basic sig, because its so big. If it would be managable, a version without Spidey in it would be cool in a Horror/Movie sig. Therefore, the usability is kinda low, exept for in wallpapers.

It must have been a hard and long cut because of his arms also.

--------------------------------------------------------

@ Dooks

Thats a very cool and unique render i must say. The render seems hard to cut because the original had all that water in it that must have made it hard to see the bottom of the boat.
The usability is also kinda high because its in a good position for a sig. A wallpaper would work also.
It would also fit in a movie sig and/or Horror sig of some kind.

Good job.

---------------------------------------------------------

So my vote goes to... Dooks!

 

I would like to say to both renderers great work guys.

RENDER A.....WOLVERINE.

Great cut can see very little wrong with this would iof been nice to get rid of the text on the tentical at the bottom.Difficutly i would give it a 8/10 the tenticals must of been very tedious work.Usability is good although could'nt really use in a sig very well.size is good i have only seen this done a couple of times so quite unique.

RENDER B.....DOOKS
Mmm not a bad cut for this one a lot of bg in places and also choppy too also the quality isnt that good either but for the most nice cut.Difficulty i would give it a 7/10 its very unique i have never seen this render before and the size is good.Usability is ok although again not to good for use in a sig but great for nething else.

MY VOTE GOES TO...

WOLVERINE for the better cut and quality of render to me more work has gone onto this render.But great job to both of you well done.

 

Wolverine gets my vote:

Difficulty - Medium
Usability - High
Image is cut nice

 

Dooks:

Difficulty - 7/10. The image doesn't look that hard to render from first glance.

How unique the render is - Pretty unique. First time I've seen it attempted.

Usability - I find it very difficult to use in signatures or wallpapers primarily because of the image itself.

How Well The Image Has Been Cut - Jagged cuts at some parts of the render, like the paddle.

Wolverine:

Difficulty - 7/10. SPIDERMAN!

How unique the render is - Not very unique. I've seem it attempted countless times but nontheless, good job in selecting it.

Usability - I suppose it would be usable in some signatures depending on how the style is approached.

How Well The Image Has Been Cut - it's pretty detailed. Smooth cuts around the edges and I've liked what you did around the tentacles of Dr. Oc. Very thorough and detailed cut.

Overall, I think Wolverine gets my vote even though it's been attempted countless number of times. The cut just looks more detailed and cleaner than Dooks.

 

Wolverine
Hehe nice render. I've never seen it done before, and not exactly the most practical render. It's a fantastic cut though and I like the cut, and pretty difficult too: 8/10! The size renders it useful for a signature or small web banner because for larger graphics it would seem out of ... place. Anyway it's a great render!

Dooks
Woah, GANDALF!!!!!!! Err... Aragorn. Or... Eowyn...!? :lol: It's a nice, large render. I've never seen this render done, either. However the cut's really kind of "lumpy" around the curves, especially the more complex ones. But this render looks quite difficult, around 7.5/10 or so. The render is good overall and useful for large web graphics Anyway great job!

My vote goes to... *drumroll*

Dooks
That was a tough decision, actually. But I'm glad I decided Great job guys!

~Nightfire

 

Wolverine

Difficulty- it doesen't look that hard, but it looks really time consuming
How unique the render is- yeah, that prett cool. spidey and..... um.. forgot his name
Usability - IS A MAJOR FACTOR!!- I think it's pretty useable. but i think if you were using it you would have to just use either spidey or........... god damn what his name?
How Well The Image Has Been Cut- great cut
Size - NOTE This Is Not A Major Factor.- great size

Dooks

Difficulty- doesen't look that hard either, just very time consuming
How unique the render is- yeah, I have never seen somthing like that
Usability - IS A MAJOR FACTOR!! I don't think it's very useable. just one color and it would stretch across the whole sig. and the image quality isn't good, too blurry.
How Well The Image Has Been Cut- the cut is ok. it's pretty choppy and dodgy in some place, but other than that gj. I don't think that's something that I would render.
Size - NOTE This Is Not A Major Factor.- great size

GMV to Wolverine. his render wins flat out in every category
except uniqueness

 

It's called Octopus