Blzrd Vs. Dooks

Winners Bracket

Renders will be judged on:
Difficulty
How unique the render is
Usability - IS A MAJOR FACTOR!!
How Well The Image Has Been Cut
Size - NOTE This Is Not A Major Factor.

BLzRD:

Original:

http://img212.imageshack.us/img212/3752/rfonline9xc.jpg

Rendered:



Dooks:

Original:

http://www.gamewallpapers.com/members/view...1_1200x1600.jpg

Rendered:

 

JUDGES MAY VOTE HERE NOW.

 

AHEM, JUDGES, VOTE!!!

 

ZOMG KAZUYA LOVES WRITING IN CAPITAL LETTERS!
*well, since you asked so nicely*


Blzrd

Difficulty - medium
How unique the render is - i have seen the same thing rendered before, but i dont think iv'e seen the same picture rendered.
Usability - HIGH
Cut - A very nice clean cut, no majorly noticable mistakes
Size - Good size.

Dooks

Difficulty - medium
How unique the render is - Been done MANY times before
Usability - Medium
Cut - A pretty good clean cut by the looks of it but bad use of feathering which has given the render a nasty looking outline
Size - Good.

------
My vote goes to.......
------
*drum roll*
------
scroll down.
------
keep going..
------
BlzrD

 

Wow... this one's gonna be tough. Let's see what my logical thinking process can do here

Blzrd
Great work on the cut, i'd say it's about a 6/10 difficulty, not too hard. It's quite large, which is nice, and very smooth. It's not exactly useful for much beyond signatures, however. Beautiful cut, I like it alot

Dooks
The hair is what first came to my attention. While it looks sort of "jaggy" the attention to the overall detail for the hair was amazing. I'd give it a difficulty of 9/10, the hair is what gave it such a high difficulty. I cannot find any sections of this cut that could've been done better. I like it alot. It's not too practical but is useful for web graphics and signatures, mostly, while the size is the only limit to what it can be used for. Great job!

Okay.... *drum roll*

my vote goes to...


hehe... this is going to be good....


okay... my vote goes to:

Dooks, for a more useful and practical render and an amazing job on the hair! Great job, both of you!

~nightfire

 

blzrd:
very good render,
usability:10/10 for tech sigs but still high usablilty overall
cut: nice and clean very good

dooks:
good render though i've seen ppl doing hue/saturation effects to get rid of that purple bg glow
usability: high, but ive seen it many time before
cut: could use a bit more work seems rough in some areas
hair could use more work




no drumroll for this one

blzrd GMV

 

NEED MORE VOTES HERE

 

BLzRD:

Awesome quality on the render ...very usuable and its a nice cut.

Only one thing There is a white line under the right knee cap...i don't know if its supposed to be there but that caught my eye.




Dooks:

Great cut on the render...only big issue is there is kinda a glow to it ...which i don't know if you meant it like that but its a little obvious.

Its very usuable and the hair is cut very smooth and very detailed.

Both Renderers great job

but my vote goes with
Dooks

 

dooks your stuff is good man nice cut smooth but not so usable
blazrd your is really good and is smoother and more usable.

 

This is a hard one for me.

The 1st render would be great in a techy sig; i don't see any mistakes, looks like a clean cut.
The 2nd render is also a great cut-out, but imo its a bit more whored than the 1st.

Sooo my vote goes tooooooo

Blzrd

 

Thats exactly my thought, blzrd looks alot easier to do than dooks render with the hair =).

 

5-3 - Just need a few more votes!!

 

Emm..maybe 5-2?

 

Dooks GMV. Much better render, better cuts, looks more premium. Not to mention 'twas a harder render.

 

First i would like to say to both renderers great job on these they both look great.

RENDER A.....BLzrD

exellent cut on this render i cannot find any flaws in it very smooth.Difficulty i would rate at a 6/10 the size is very good.Usability i would say is good again due to the size.Have seen this render a few times been used but not to sure if i have actually seen this version of it.

RENDER B.....DOOKS

Again a nice cut but to me either to much feather or to much blur has been used on it.hair has been done really well but i few bits of bg left.Difficulty i would give it a 7/10 size of the render is nice.Useability i would say again is high.The render has been whored a bit but that takes nothing from the fact that its still a great render.

MY VOTE GOES TO.....

BLzrD the cut on this is near perfect and the usability is good to the other render just missed out because of the cut due to the feathering that has seemed to leave a slight glow around the whole image.But both again great renders it was a close call on this one good job both of you