Winners Bracket Renders will be judged on: Difficulty How unique the render is Usability - IS A MAJOR FACTOR!! How Well The Image Has Been Cut Size - NOTE This Is Not A Major Factor. }Soc{Saint: Original: http://www.gamewallpapers.com/viewwallpape...gehog&nummer=02 Rendered: Huy-N: Original: http://www.exoload.info/106/1136685636.jpg Rendered:
soc saint: Difficulty: 5/10 not that hard, i dont see any big areas where it would be hard to render, very straight forward how unique the render is?: common sight, seen it done times before, but the ender seemed too easy Usability: 9/10 seen it many time before in other ppl's sigs Cut: 9.5/10, those feathers on his chest are a bit messed up but other than taht i see no errors, but the rifle could use more work Size: good size but that's what made this cut so easy Huy-N: Difficulty: 8/10 those flames must have been hardas they match the bg in the original Uniqueness: seen it a couple of times before Usability: 7.5/10 i dont see this one being used these days Cut:9.5/10 very good but the flames are a bit off from the original Size: good size made it easy to render it except for the flame part HuyN GMV
Saint Difficulty - not too difficult Uniqness - quite unique, hasn't been done before that iv'e seen Usability - VERY usable indeed! How Well The Image Has Been Cut - A very clean cut, cant notice any major flaws. Size - meh.. Huy N Difficulty - extremely easy Uniqness - has been done many times before, all of which better cuts tbh. Usability - nice an usable How Well The Image Has Been Cut - The actuall cut on the image seems quite nice, however its squared off in places were the curves arn't perfected. The glow at first glance seems quite good, but when you look over it again the film is in places where it shouldn't be and squares off at the top. Size - meh.. -------- Saint gmv, overall better use of the PEN tool.
}Soc{Saint: It looks like about a 5/10 difficulty cut on that. It is not that unique because ive seen it many times before on gamerenders and other forums. It is a regular size. It is very well cut, very clean and all. It is very usable in almost everykind of gfx!! Huy-N: It looks like a 8/10 difficulty cut, those flames look greatly cut clean and all, it isnt unique because ive seen it before many times. it is very usable in any type of gfx and is a great size !! ------ I vote for: ------ Huy-N ------ Because of his great flame work !! ------
}Soc{Saint: difficulty: 4.5/10 Nothing hard about this render very easy edges to cut nothing hard abou this render how unique the render is?: This Render is actually unique i have not seen this one before. Usability: 8.7/10 yes i see its a usuable render great quality. Cut: 9.2/10 good cut the chest hairs doesn't seem right though might need to look at that again..but nothing about this cut is argueable. Size: Descent Huy-N Difficulty: 3.9/10 Very easy render...i say that becuase even though the flames are intemidating they have large color shade differences then that of the back ground making it easy to render. Unique: Yes its unique i've not seen this one before Usability: 6.7/10 I couldn't honestly see how to use it since the flames cuase a problem of taking up so much of the sig its self. Cut: 8.7/10 its not perfect....also look under his arm pit you missed a spot My vote goes to: }Soc{Saint
}Soc{Saint: This is a real step down from your entry in the first round. The render is simple. But it is really common the size is good. Huy-N:I like how you did the transparency. The flames were cut. The flames must of been a reel pain to cut also Huy-N gets my vote.
}soc{saint When I saw this render ... my jaw dropped open... It's an amazing render - quite large and the cut is spectacular. Except for the finger around the trigger which seemed to cut through the trigger area. This looks to be very useful for signatures and banners, but since some areas of the image are cut off it won't be necessarily useful for wallpapers. Great job m8! Huy-n When I saw saint's render, my jaw dropped open, but I squealed with delight when I saw the fire in this render! Amazing, and spectacular job on the fire. It's slightly... blocky around some edges but barely noticable, especially if it's blended. The size is adequate for wallpapers, I suppose, but sigs and web graphics are dominant here on GR and that's what it's best for Amazing! *drum roll* And the vote goes to... Huy-n - w00t great rendering, m8! Good job, guys ~nightfire
Huy-N gets my vote because although both renders are of comprable size, quality and usibility, the thing that sets them apart is the difficulty. I think Huy-N's render was more difficult with the flames and all. Nice job to both contestants.
Soc: Rendered very well. Nice and smooth on the rendering. The render itself is average difficulty. NOt too hard to distinguish the render from the BG, and very smooth rendering. I have seen this rendered a lot though... Huy: Rendered very well. Not difficult on the body of the render itself, but the flames are marvelously rendered. You missed a little part where his sword meets his body, but it's not too bad. Also a little choppy by his right thigh. But overall, I just feel that Huy had to spend more time rendering his over Socs. so.... Huy-N GMV
to both renderers good job guys... RENDER A....}Soc{Saint Very nice cut very little wrong with it nice smooth cut a few little flaws but nothing worth mentioning.Difficulty is middle of the road 4/10.useability high nice size too. RENDER B.....Huy-n nice cut the flames on this render are done by a technique that i dont agree with though.difficulty is again middle of the road 4/10.useability is very good nice size too to me it doesnt matter if it has been done many times before so that has no factor in the vote... MY VOTE GOES TO..... }Soc{Saint again very close battle and well done to both of you...
Saint GMV. That is a much more unique render. The wallpaper was blurry, colored smeared, etc. Harder cut, besides the fire on Huy's.
hard hard hard choice for me... Both renders are great cuts; nothing wrong with them; also both are very usable. Also both are not really unique. The only thing imo that separate them is the hardness rate: imo Huy-N's is a little bit more hard than Siants, so i vote for... Huy-n
