Tweaker_ Vs -forevertrue-

Tweaker_'s entree:

Original:



Rendered:




-ForeverTrue-'s entree:

Original:

Not recieved.

Rendered:

 

JUDGES MAY VOTE HERE NOW

 

*yawns* Can't believe I woke up to judge this morning....

Anyway lets begin here

Tweaker_: I like the render its simple and effective I can't really find anything wrong with it.


-ForeverTrue-: Due to simple human error I will rejudge the render. It would be easier if I could see the original because the stuff sticking out of Yoshimitsu is choppy. Everything is good expect the things sticking out of Yoshimitsu. Its useably and a good size. I like Tekken but it is a tad choppy in the area.

So once again Tweaker_ gets my vote

 

OKAY! now ForeverTrue's render is up. It's very useful but fairly small, and choppy/blurry in a lot of places. My final vote is:

Tweaker!

ORIGINAL MESSAGE:
-------------------------------------------------------------------

why is ForeverTrue's render NOT showing up? please fix this, Kazuya/whoever posted the image

:lol:

anyway Tweaker

There is some choppiness but the demands of this image give it a difficulty of 8/10! good work, i like it. It is not very useful, however, for signatures; this could be used for web graphics and wallpapers.

GameRenders is quite slow right now so perhaps that's the reason to ForeverTrue's render not displaying?



Happy New Year!

~nightfire

 

Here is the render:

As i said.
Mystical.. this is the real render.. The one i sent to kazuya by mistake was the messed up one.. which i didnt want my entree to be.
it was a mistake.
aboth is the real render.
so please judge me again.
thank you.
and NightFire.. there is my render man

 

chopiness around the back or him. Or It Could Be My Firefox. Like On Those THings Comign Out Of His Neck The Bakc off Him..

 

Tweaker_'s entree:

difficulty:medium
size:big
quality: very nice !! clean cut !!
usability: very usable in any kind of gfx

-ForeverTrue-'s entree:

difficulty: unknown becasue of missing original
size:normal
quality: nice clean cut all around
usability: only usable in sigs

i vote for

Tweaker_

 

Kazuya agreed on me being a temporary judge.

Everything is explained from my point of view, so If I am referring to right or left-side, it will be our right or left.

Tweaker_:

1st thought
- Nice picture, I like anime

Mistakes
- You cut away a part of the picture on the left hair-strand
- Some minor white spots on one of the ropes
- Some black outlining on some hair-strands (and others haven’t got that, please choose either with black, or without black outlining).
- Some choppyness on some hair-strands

Positive
- Nice difficult picture, a good thing to show your render-abilities

Negative
- A bit too much details and tiny things to use in a sig.


-ForeverTrue-:

1st thought
- weird but simple picture

Mistakes
- a white spot between his middlefinger and ringfinger
- a white line on top of the left foot
- a little choppy around the blade

Positive
- Nice cut, almost no mistakes
- Good size for sigs

Negative
- there are some parts of the picture that look choppy, but I’m not sure, because of the missing original



My vote goes to ForeverTrue, for making a good render, that is more usable

if you a better explanation containing pictures, please pm me, and add link to original, render and my own comment.

 

Both renders are well cut. Here is what i have to say about each

Tweaker_ : well cut render deffinitly useable in a sig or splash. It was well cut for being done on such a light background.

-forevertune - : it looks like a decent render, although ever so choppy in a couple spots, still usable. I am not sure how difficult this was though because i do not have an original image.

Tweaker_ gets my vote beause i feel that his was more complex and still usable

 

Since ForeverTrue's n3 is choppy my vote goes to Tweaker.

 

5 - 1 To Tweaker!

Two more votes and the battle is over!

 

Tweaker_ GMV. Much better cut, lots of rough edges and mistake on other, and no original is kind of hard to decifer.

 

Tweaker_: very good render, dont see errors
difficulty: 7.5/10 that's alot of hair
usage: usable

ForeverTrue: whao man those spikes w/e are real choppy, i can even see the background on some of them, and it is a bit choppy in other areas too
difficulty:i say around 5/10 seems pretty easy, no small areas except for the hand
usage: ... dunt know but i could see ppl using this render without hte spikes



tweaker GMV because of the hair, sorry ForeverTrue, just those spikes screwed you up

 

Can't see either render being used, so on with skill.

Tweaker_'s render is of higher quality, larger, and not fuzzy.

^ GMV.

 

Tweaker wins.

7 - 1.