Ichigo91 Vs Cloud Reloaded

JUDGES MAY VOTE HERE NOW

Ichigo91's entree:

Original:

Lost.

Rendered:




CloudReloaded's entree:

Original:



Rendered:

 

JUDGES MAY VOTE HERE NOW.

 

Heh, this is really getting on my nerves. One render does not show up...? why is that? It seems to be occurring much to often in this Render of the Year section.... :lol: that's okay, I'll voice my comments on CloudReloaded's entry anyway.

CloudReloaded
HAIR! WOW! The image is very large, but at first glance it looks rather simple to do. Actually, the hair probably adds a +4 difficulty to it on a x/10 scale, so it'd be about a 9/10 difficulty! It's an amazing cut, the hair is outstanding! I like it alot. The image is very useful for wallpapers and web graphics, and even signatures! Bravo!

Okay, so my vote obviously goes to CloudReloaded since the image for Ichigo91 was not there. Even so, I'd have voted for CloudReloaded anyway, no matter what render would be submitted in battle against this one! Amazing work m8, keep it up!

Happy New Year!

~nightfire

 

Ichigo91's entree:

difficulty: hard to say without original
size:big
quality: very nice clean cut all the way around
usability: its usable !!

CloudReloaded's entree:

difficulty:extremly hard
sizeerfect
quality: very very nice clean cut !! i dont see anything wrong with it !!
uability: very very very usable !!

i vote for

CloudReloaded

 

Kazuya agreed on me being a temporary judge.

Everything is explained from my point of view, so If I am referring to right or left-side, it will be our right or left.

Ichigo91

1st thought
- OMFG that’s huge!

Mistakes
- a little wavy around the orange part of her belt
- a little cubic around her shoes

Positive
- Cant find much wrong with the render.
- Very big size, very good for wallpapers in any size
- Clean and simple picture
- Original

Negative
- Very big and tall, so it would’nt fit on a sig properly


CloudReloaded

1st thought
- OMG you did all those hairs??!!!

Mistakes
- hairs are choppy
- some choppy parts on her legs

Positive
- Good size
- Original

Negative
- Sad that the picture is halfly cut off



My vote goes to Ichigo, cuz his render is more than usable, it’s ----ing huge!

if you a better explanation containing pictures, please pm me, and add link to original, render and my own comment.

 

I've been avoiding this one

@Ichigo91:Well you have size on your size. Its a nice render and a nice cut there really isn't anything wrong with it unless I feel like doing a in-depth analysis.

@CloudReloaded: The tips of the hair are a bit choppy. I like the size of the render and the qualitiy of the cut is..above average..?

Both are useable and good cuts each with an equal amount of faults. But I have to vote for CloudReloaded

 

Both renders are good quality and are well cut

Ichigo91 : the render is of a good size, its well cut and deffintily usable in anything from sigs, to banners and wallpappers.

Cloud Reloaded : the render is of a medium size, unique, and has uses limited to either sigs or banners.

Ichigo91 gets my vote because his render is of a great size, good quality and is usable in a variety of things.

 

It's way to easy rendering an anime render with a black outline. CloudReloaded's renders hair is great.

CR, gmv.

 

NEED MORE VOTES

4 - 3 SO FAR

 

CloadReloaded GMV. I think its more professionally cut, as anime tends to be easier.. Sorry, not much to explain.

 

Ichigo91: It's a nice render,
Usability is high also ..

CloadReloaded: Very nice render,
High Usability .. Hair cut is awesome!

CR gets my vote!

 

wo ima judge now
ichigo91:dificulty: it was real big but it had hard areas, i say 8/10
usage:very usable in fact i'm using this one for a frineds sig req and i can see other ppl using this one too
overall: good render but i still cna see mistaeks on her sandals and ribbon on her head i'm surprised you even tried to do taht one because of it's size

cloudreloaded: difficulty:8/10 it would have been 9.5/10 if you took out the stars on her body/guns
usage: i dont see alot of ppl using this one
overall: nicely done but the legs seem a bit choppy, and other areas as well. Nice render over all espically the hair


my vote is for cloud reloaded

 

CR wins 6 - 3.