Titan. Vs Pro Evo Graphics

JUDGES MAY VOTE HERE NOW

Titan.'s Entree:

Original:

Could not find due to computer issues.

Rendered:



Pro Evo Graphics' Entree:

Original:



Rendered:

 

JUDGES MAY VOTE HERE NOW

 

Titan.'s Entree:

difficulty: unkown doo to lost of original
size: normal
quality: nice cut !!! clean all the way around !!
usability: i dont really see myself personally usign this and i dont see what people can do with it !!

Pro Evo Graphics' Entree:

difficulty: medium to hard do because of the colour blending of render and background
sizeerfect
quality: nice clean cut all around !!
usability: very usable in preatty much any gfx

i vote for

Pro Evo Graphics

 

Titan
This is a good render, although it's very small. The details are nicely

rendered; this looks to be about 6/10 in terms of difficulty. NOT a very

practical image at all, unless you want a render of 50Cent on your signature or

web graphic :lol: Good render!

Pro Evo Graphics
Yet another stunning render from Pro Evo Graphics. The attention to detail is

nice, the hair was rendered well too, although it doesn't look too difficult,

about 7/10, I'd assume. The strange color is indeed... strange... but that's

what I just said.... ^_^ Too bad you couldn't find one that was normally

colored, we could change the hue/saturation in Photoshop anyway LOL
It's a large render; the render itself is useful for wallpapers, mainly, and

web graphics and signatures.
Good job, overall!

My vote goes to Pro Evo Graphics for another quality render!
Congratulations! Thanks to the both of you for submitting your renders!

Happy New Year!

~nightfire

 

Titan
His usealibity of the render is very good. I can see it in just about anything.
Cant judge on diffuclty cuz no original was provided.
Very Clean Cut.
Size is decent
Its pretty unique not a normal type of render

Pro Evo Graphics
Render is very useable
Its an average diffuclty to cut.
Very very nice quality.
Perfect Size
It is cut a lot so its not very unique.

Pro Evo Gets My vote but the cuts are very good from both of you.

 

Kazuya agreed on me being a temporary judge.

Everything is explained from my point of view, so If I am referring to right or left-side, it will be our right or left.

Titan.:
1st thought
- cool and original

Mistakes
- a slight white spot on the left eh… thing. You know.. the one that sticks out
- a slight white line on another small thing on the left. (near his ear). Also a part of his equipment on his back (damn what a confusing picture).
- Some slight white lines on the right big wing-like thing
- Some black outlining on the white part of his hat and on the tip of the left guns
- A black line on the right-side of his belt and on the right-side of his neck
- Some cubic places on some parts of the entire render

Positive
- Good size
- Good on both dark and light backgrounds
- Very original


Pro Evo Graphics:
1st thought
- Nice and bright picture, only sad that her head is partly chopped off.

Mistakes
- a bit choppy around the hair
- some light outline on her left shoulder (our left)
- some cubic places over on the bottom-right and between the laces of her glove on the left side.
- A missed black spot on the right “braid?” (lock of hair)

Positive
- nice picture that has very usable color, and will look nice in a sig

Negative
- a bit large (not in size, but in screen-filling. If you draw a cubic around it, it would fill almost everything)



titan gets my vote, because his render just looks more usable, and the mistakes are smaller than on Pro Evo's render. Both did a good job

if you a better explanation containing pictures, please pm me, and add link to original, render and my own comment.

 

This may be difficult...-.-"

@Titan: Its useable and unique there is a white spot on the hat which makes it look weird. Overall a great render but simple

@Pro Evo Graphics. I don't really like the choice of render its just a bit to monotone imo. The hair is kinda strange.

My choice goes to Titan because its more useable and its unique. I also like the simplicity of it.

 

Both are interesting choices of renders

Titan. : well cut, but the size is only good for sigs or banners. I'm not too sure on the difficulty because i do not have an original to go by

Pro Evo Graphics: very nice size and well cut image, you could use that easily in a sig or banner

Pro Evo Graphics gets my vote on size and how well it was cut, great job both of you.

 

Titan.

I really like this one. I can see myself using it, I don't find it small. I think its a good size, and there is actually a function you can resize images with, all you that complained... <_< Clean cut, 0% choppyness, that my eye doesn't spot.

Pro evo graphics.
It's a very whored render. The hair looks like its "stuck" togheter. Like her hair is fat-ish. The render itself is hard to use because the elbow is cut off. Overall a good job.

I was leaning at PEG at first. But then I saw an outline on some parts of it.

and when I look at both on the same time.. I find Titans. much better (IMO).

So Titan GMV.

 

5-2 To Pro Evo Graphics so far!

Just a few more votes, comon!!

 

Pro Evo Graphics GMV. Harder cut, etcetc, above comments.

 

Couldn't have summed it up better then that, i agree 100%.

 

6 - 3 To Pro Evo Graphics!!

2 More Votes will seal his victory >_<

 

They Are Both Very Nice

 

hehe this battle's closed - i can't believe there are new posts here

seems some of you have outdone me in the excellence of your votes. anyway, thanks to all who have voted and contributed to the ROTY for 2006!

~Nightfire