-Truimph-: Original: http://www.gamewallpapers.com/wallpapers.php?titel=Killzone Rendered: Huy-N: Original: Rendered:
-Truimph-: looks like a medium difficulty render, nice size, very choppy not that clean of a cut and not that usable sry Huy-N: looks like a medium difficulty render, a bit big but who cares, nice clean cut very usable !! gj i vote for Huy-N
Triumph Your render is good, but it's not very good in terms of quality. It's slightly choppy in places and is fairly small, but can be easily blended in for signatures and web graphics. There is not much practical purpose for it, however. Good job, though. Huy-N This render is large, high-quality and wonderfully cut. You did an amazing job on the hair - REALLY amazing. +rep for you! Great job, Huy-N. This is good for wallpapers, signatures, banners and all kinds of graphics. Keep it up! My vote goes to... HUY-N! CONGRATS M8! keep it up! Happy New Year! ~Nightfire
both real nice renders total opposites to triumph has a nice render going on but i feel its to bright would be hard to work with in a sig where as huyhas a nice cloean cut large and very workable so huy gets my vote
-Truimph-:Well first of all the feathering you did really brings down the render. I think you cut off there boots too. Which really doesn't benefit you in this competition. Huy-N: Its quite good useable and theres nothing wrong with it so there really any faults to comment on. My vote goes to Huy-N
This one was tough, both looks really cool. Im leaning towards Triumph, because its good for manips,sigs and big pieces. The difficulty of it isnt too big though. But then again i find it better then the other one. Triumph gmv.
Both are well cut renders i belive. Here is how my voting breaks down Trimph- Pretty well cut but im not sure how usable it would be due to its size and the quality of it Huy-N- very nice render its well cut and the quility is very good. Size is not a question, it is large enough to be used with nearly anything. Great job both of you, but Huy-N gets my vote.
thanks for all the voters, Even I admit Huy-N's is much better then mine, its only my 4th cut, it came out worse then i thought thats ok Good render Huy-n
Kazuya agreed on me being a temporary judge. Everything is explained from my point of view, so If I am referring to right or left-side, it will be our right or left. Triumph: 1st thought - Weird picture Mistakes - White outline around the pants of the 1st soldier - White outline around the hand of the 3th soldier - White outline around the pants of the 2nd soldier - Left background in the armpit of the 3th soldier - Left background around the right hand of the 3th soldier - Outline around the heads of the 2nd and 3th soldier - Choppyness around the whole picture Negative - Bad picture choice - Size is too much screenfilling. Huy-N 1st thought - pretty decent picture - Original DOESN’T match rendered. The render is bigger in size. Mistakes - weird colored hair strands - left background over on the right shoulder (that metal thing) - black outline around the right shoulder - choppy around the headband Positive - Nice work around the hair Negative - size is too much screenfilling My vote goes to Huy-N, cuz his picture is more usable, and he made a better cut if you a better explanation containing pictures, please pm me, and add link to original, render and my own comment.
