JUDGES MAY VOTE HERE NOW Demon_Lord's Entree: Original: Rendered: *XYZ*TinX's Entree: Original: Rendered:
hmm I'd go for xyz the flames should have proved quite difficult and its more usable.really smooth behind the black scenes yours looks better demon lord:good cut but it cant be used much. I also feel behind the black that could do much more work.
hmm.. A difficult choice. @Demon Lord:A good cut its useable. But its not a good size for that kind of render. I don't think you should of scaled the img down either. Overall its a good job @*XYZ*TinX': Interesting choice of render. But it has been done many times before lowering the uniqueness of the render it has a good size. Useable which is obvious seeing the sigs that have that whored render in it. So my vote goes toward *XYZ*TinX'
Daemon Great cut, and it's large too, which is nice. Usability is at a minimum, it is usable but not for much. *XYZ*TinX You get my vote - it's an amazing cut and very useful for banners, signatures, wallpapers, web graphics and etc. Great job, keep it up! Happy New Year! ~nightfire
Man I just want to start off by saying they these both look amazing !! Demon_Lord:Looks like it was a medium/hard render to do because of the colour contrast and all that, The size is good !! Nice clean cut, but now for the Usability part , I personnaly find that isnt that usable (well that's my opignion). *XYZ*TinX: Looks like it was very hard to render !! (i am actually trying to render the same image but my version of it dosent have any fire and im having problems with it). Perfect size. Nice Clean cut all away around and the fire look's great, I find that it is VERY usable in a sig !! My vote goes to !! *XYZ*TinX
Demon_Lord: It's pretty good, size is good. Its abit choppy on the foot, but its hardly noticeable. Very good job. *XYZ* TinX: Amazing. Best render I've seen of this wallpaper. Its very usable in sigs. Size is good. my vote goes to *XYZ* TinX.
*XYZ* TinX gets my vote also large quality is great and could easily be blended with in a sig banner or wall demonlords is nice but i find the quality to be low and not a great usability in sigs in general
Kazuya agreed on me being a temporary judge. Everything is explained from my point of view, so If I am referring to right or left-side, it will be our right or left. Demon Lord 1st thought - nice, but very fake looking picture Mistakes - some light spots and lines around the predators hair - a white line around the left claw of the alien - some choppyness around the left claw of the predator - it would look better if the drool of the alien was more translucent Positive - nice picture, lot’s of stuff going on, good for wallpapers Negative - not good for small things as sigs and avatars, caused by all the things going on. XYZ*TinX 1st thought - nice picture! Mistakes - The fire looks weird - Some white lines around some parts of his weapon - Some hair-strands seem to be glued together instead of separate - Some choppyness around the hair Positive - nice sized picture Negative - the fire made it look ugly My vote goes to XYZ*TinX, cuz I like that picture, and it is still usable if you a better explanation containing pictures, please pm me, and add link to original, render and my own comment.
Nice job both of you for some very well cut renders. Demon_lord: well cut render and fairly difficult, but im not sure how usable it would be *xyz*tinx : very nice render, great size and it looks pretty difficult, deffinitly usable. *xyz*tinx gets my vote for a very nice and useable render, great job
