Kazuya: I love the smoothness, no choppyness on the edges, extra + because it's big, and it's a good useable render. snobird: The other one is a render of Kazuya (right?), and I don't think anyone would use it in a sig, and the hair is messy, and there's odd edges on it... Like where to eyebrow is on the left side.. Seems like a half-arsed job in my opinion. Kazuya get's my vote.
Well its plainly obvious its Kazuya... @Kazuya:Its nice and smooth not to mention its actually useable @snobird: snobirds is really choppy and I don't like how he tried to hide it with feathering not to mention its not even saved as .png. and can someone tell me how the hell you would use a small picture of Kazuya in a sig or anything?! So my vote goes to Kazuya
I think this says it all !! but ill still vote like i should Kazuya: Look's like a medium difficulty render, Nice size nice cut, very usabal, nice clean cut !! snobird: can i really say anything about this ?? to small unsuabel very choppy !! Vote for: Kazuya
Kazuya Your render is great, it's very practical and very large, usable for anything. The cut is amazing, some parts could be improved but overall it's great. Snobird Wow. Eh, it's a decent cut; the render itself is very impractical and useless. Also, it's quite small, which is not very good. Keep trying, m8! CONGRATULATIONS, KAZUYA! You get my vote! Happy New Year! ~nightfire
Kazuya: smooth and highly usable, could have worked on a glow around the cape though. Snobird: no comment? fairly obvious who i vote for, no?
Kazuya agreed on me being a temporary judge. Everything is explained from my point of view, so If I am referring to right or left-side, it will be our right or left. Kazuya: 1st thought - original looks beautiful Mistakes - small outline around her wristbands - you cut off a small part of the right shoe - there is a small pixel left in her ponytail - missed spots in the flower in her hair - at some parts a small outline around the cloth (that white thing that she is playing with) Positive - very clean cut - nice picture - good to use Negative - the cloth on the original has movement, the cloth on the render doesn’t Snobird 1st thought - AAAAH MY EYES!! Mistakes - containing a background - choppy in the neck - weird around the left eyebrow - cut-off part above the right ear Positive - Humour - original Negative - Bad picture choice - Too small - Not that usable My vote goes to Kazuya, cuz his render is more usable and has a better cut if you a better explanation containing pictures, please pm me, and add link to original, render and my own comment.
Kazuya - Very nicely Cut - Very Useable - Fairly medium difficult to render Snobird - Not bad render - Good for DART PRACTICING-lol - Unuseable My vote goes to ... Kazuya Due to the cutting and usability of the render compared to Snobirds 7-0 to Kazuya
Kazuya : nice cut, great quality great size and very usable Snobird : um.. its not very big and not very usable and its fairly well cut. Kazuya gets my vote because his render is much more practical and is well cut
