Midnight 1st is too big, text looks off 6/10 2nd lens flare is way too obvious more depth needed too 7/10
^ 8.6/10- Nice pattern on the back. I like that color Good text too. 9.0/10- Wow. Very nice bg and render. Good text and looks really nice overall.
1st: 7/10 not liking the size. the lightsaber looks wack O-o 2nd: text needs work 8/10 3rd: 7/10 a bit too much contrast on the smudging
2nd one i like too, maybe blend the left side of the render a bit. . .sweet text and background though 7.5/10 the noob