Shinn, i really like your sigs.. small but sexy all overal 8,8/10 when rating me also rate this with it it's a manip original here
for some reason, it wont let me see the original image on the manip but for the other two, i give ya a 7.5 and a 6
.5/10 Too Large, text is bad, just like a red background with a HEAVY pattern on it, and like 20 px border and 20px stroke on the render. Sorry, bro, not liking it at all. I just gave you .5 because it's...something.
Lucky Kevin Nice style on all, not spectacular though more depth needed. . . 7.5/10. . . halo one i like more 8/10
colors on the first two are great 9/10 third could use some lighting work and text is a little random 7/10.
I'd say 8.5/10 to 9/10 Nice sigs you got there but one second one im not feeling that white brushing in the bottom of sig
no offense but i dont really ike urs (i tihnk its teh renders) so hmm 6/10 here steh 1 to rate(i made earlier)