Rate The Sig Above You ..

both deserve a 7.5/10, nice job on both, lighting looks good just the text i guess is a lil out of wack lol.

 

both are 9/10 the only thing i can say is fix the text on the second and to work on lighting it would look better if it was darker and the majority light came from the one area where it looks like an explosion but still nice work.

 

8/10
the bg is really! really good

 

8.5/10 for the 2nd the bg is really nice

 

Top.
Render needs some blending and the text is a little boring. Rest is great.
- 8/10

Bottom.
Not feeling the lighting at all, maybe use a gradient and ahve it fade out at the bottom. I dont like the render and the right side needs blending, bg doesnt work to well with the rest of the sig and the render takes up to much space. I like the text effects and everything, but the colors are off imo.
- 6/10

 

8.5/10 i liked the way u did the text in the other version

 

it's pretty good but you need to improce your techniques a bit, then it will turn out very nice!!

8/10 overall.

 

8/10 i like it

 

7/10, dont really like this one.. it's to standard looks just a motion blur in the background.. text is fine tho

thinkyou followed schleprok tutorial.. am i right?

 

a little monotone, but good.
8/10

 

no i don't, hmm yeah bg is motion blur and some other filters ;>

 

didnt rate mine anyways, i like and i commented on the thread

 

I like abstract, so: [8 / 10]


Nice, I like the colors to


Edit for the next person who's gonna rate my sig: Yeah, my sig is plain, I know, I wanna have an easy sig

 

6.5/10
nothing special =/