PT Submission #37

http://www.gamerenders.com/forum/index.php...pic=160980&st=0

 

I dont like it. He doesnt go into detail, at all. Doesnt explain anything. He doesnt show the C4D render (which he misspelled "CD4" btw), he doesnt show the guy render. He pretty much tells you what to do and you guess the rest of it. I dont think the smudging was good.. And I dident learn too much from tut. Final result was decent, but text sucked. Tut could've looked better in general.

No.

 

I agree with master. If he put more work and detail into it, I would have said yes, but he didn't. The outcome looks good though, but my vote is still no

 

what master said.

the outcome is poor imo too.

 

Same reasons as above, i really dont like the outcome and he isnt much descriptive in my opinion.

No.

 

meh i agree with u all but its unique style ;
my vote is No

 

Final Vote: No