Rate The Sig Above You ..

ratings here are pretty harsh huh

first, everything fits pretty much, I'm not a fan of LP really but it looks nice, not to keen on how much of the bg shows through their faces in places but I dunno if thats your blending or the original image

8/10

second, nice blending on the render, bg gives a sense of chaos, maybe could do with a little more depth and the orange colour in the text is a bit too bright for the sig I think.

8.5/10

 

Not Bad although could use some blending.

8/10

 

I don't like text. Also it's too chaotic for me. 7/10

 

its decent but im not really feeling it it seems to .......something like its doesnt seem to fit 8/10.

 

1ste need some work around the text 7/10
2nd the render doesn't quiet fit the bqckground 7,5/10

 

Like em both, specially the simplicty of the first one

9/10

8/10

 

5/10
no render blending
overcontrasted
I don't like it, sorry

 

9.5/10 for both of them... perfect use of blending and lighting

 

7/10 - looks good

 

^

I'll rate your first (or new) one...

8.6/10- wow good stuff. Just not diggin the text.. doesnt really match the dark and grungy background.

 

7/10 for all of them

 

7/10 like the style but not the colors

 

Work on your text a bit more. Backgrounds seem ok... (ish)
5/10 for both.

 

Kami

5/10 background doesn't match.

 

7/10 overall, the 2 first ones should blend more