Rate The Sig Above You ..

The first looks nice, but the text kills it. Unfortunately, the 2nd isn't much better. The sig seems a bit dark and empty in the bottom. Good try with the lighting tho, I think I know what effect you were going for.
1st: 7/10 (Text a no-no)
2nd 5/10 (A bit empty/dark)

 

left to right
8/10 - looks very nice but i don't like the text much
6/10 - sorry it doesn't look that good
8/10 - this one is good
9/10 - i like this the most - but the text isn't that visible

Wot da Fu-fudge!!!!! wat ya mean ya can't see it!? I can see it perfectly!

 

@zero
8/10 for the average of the 4.
i like the colors... really match the render. and the bg of course... especially the 3rd one

 

9/10 for both. Good balance on colours, lighting and open areas.

 

9.6/10 Dude. As always

 

1st - 9/10 crx's sig, great colors and bg
2nd - 7/10 i don't like bg, text needs more work

 

8/10 overall... great piece of work. nice colors.

 

^

8.2/10 pretty good smudging although i aint diggin the lines><

7.5/10 A little plain, but it prolly is that way. not my style.

 

eternalapoc
6/10 no blending, monotone color ad the left side is really plain...

 

Tipio its nice i'd rate 8/10 to much brightness and the background is to busy...

 

both 8/10 the background is pretty good but you need to work on the text some more..

 

Render on the first looks a bit blurry, or maybe it's just me, nice bg, sweet text and I really like the effect around the render (or was it with the render?)
Text is a bit hard to see, rest is very nice

8.5/10 Overall

 

9.5/10 for both. Nice text, colours and backgrounds on them. I really like them.

 

um there nice... um i don't know umm 6/10 cos there basically animated and boring, no offence

 

7.5/10 for all 3. Same style on each. Boring, no offense.