Pt Submission

http://www.gamerenders.net/forum/index.php...=0#entry1020636

Yep.. #2.

Kazuya NOT allowed to vote. You may voice your opinion, though.

 

In my honest opinion, I dont think this is quite that good. The tutorial, and end result is somewhat novice - very low inter leveled. End result isnt too good. Grammer isnt the best thing in that tutorial either; and there are many better Full Signature tutorials. Remember, we are looking for the BEST!

This one is a No.

 

Seen better full signature tutorial, and yes..the outcome isn't the greatest. Still a good tutorial, but i think we should keep a strict outcome of Premium Tutorials.

My vote is no,
BFTP

 

Hehehe, I didn't think that one would get through either :lol:

As long as me rendering an second sig tutorial get through I'm a happy chappy :lol:

 

Just so everyone knows, this is to you kazuya, we, the Staff of GameRenders, are going to be the BIGGEST bïtches ever on rating tutorials...So even some really good ones wont get through......So dont get discouraged.

And yeah, im going to be completely honest on everyones tutorials, I have noone to hide behind, or any reason to get swayed off of anything.

Btw, discussion in these threads ARE allowed.. You can vote and discuss/ask questions, etc. Feel free. That is why the poll is here, to keep that portion organized.

 

like I said, I'm not too bothered, I knew this tutorial wasn't the best as it is one of my past ones :lol:

But if my latest two don't get through then I'll be bitching like crazy :lol:

 

I voted no because really the outcome isn't the best. There are PLENTY of tutorials that use the EXACT same technique, with the exact same outcome, and to me, it doesn't look that great .

 

Yea, i'd say no on this one. I actually liked the result of just going halfway through step 4...

 

Five more "No"'s, and topic closure.

 

well i think we know all the reasons now.
so sorry kax, but my vote is no to.

 

I know I said the same thing about the other tutorial in here now... but... to be honest. same exact opinion on this one... really.

I went with a yes also for the fact it is extremely detailed, and easy to follow. I'm not too keen on the outcome, but it is well done overall.

For now, just having a few nicely detailed tuts is good. But further down the line it would be better to only take the ones with really really nice outcomes. No offense Kaz.

 

This tutorial isnt as good as some of the other ones. The outcome is *sorry kaz* horrible TBH. (Yes Im going to be a bitch.)You got a few spelling mistakes and these stuff >.< all over, so.

No.

 

sorry, no, detailed, perhaps, but spelling isnt very correct and its not very original, and the result isnt really astounding either.

 

Somewhat I have to disagree with you.

Premium tutorials mean GOOD tutorials, awesome outcomes, etc. Not just that it was written well. I could write an awesome tutorial on Toilets with Purple Lights, perfectly do everything, images, etc. That ofcourse doesnt mean its premium.

Anyways, 2 more "No"'s, and this tutorial will Fail.

 

Just put me out my misery an' close this :lol:

An' I'll disagree wit' whoever said I mis-spelled stuff, cuz I didn't! Sure I abbreaviated a few things, but the rest was good! :lol: