Bg; looks ok, but its just brushing i think Render+render effects: Not really blended Text: Sorry, not very good. 6,5/10
6/10 for first, not bad, but use a sans serif font, custom fonts don't work in those kind of sigs. second. 5/10. vertical text is a BIG no-no in sigs, and you should at least lower the opacity of the border and the bar behind the text.
First one not my taste ! But nice coloring ! 7.5/10 The other one the render makes the sig but it owns so 8.5/10 because of a feeling of flow! Double D