Well it's not meant to be rated on the typical "brush" methods. It's the basis of how well the animation was executed and the creativity of it. 1st sig- 7/10 The colours seem a tad dull, maybe give it a tad more contrast. 2cnd sig- 8.5/10 Alot better. Nice bg colours matching the renders. Good job.
Interceptor 1- 8/10 Pretty cool. I like the theme going on. I just think the black areas are overtaking the coloured areas a tad too much. 2- 8/10 Very cool look to it. I just think the right side is too empty, perhaps move the render over to the right a bit more?
1st - Nice effects and cool looking 2nd - Not that cool, it isn't so nice to look at , add some eyecandy