noc got my vote, not sure i like the size of vash's, plus noc's is really nicelyu blended/original/ flows really nicely. pretty nic esig too vash, just dont like the size. and not enough red in the b/g good job both!
vash get my vote better render and text noc- your sig is beautiful but the subject is not clear and the light blu/ white effect of the sphear doesn't fill really good with the BG