I like the first one with the Balrog. Nice effects and the render blends well. Hmm, wheres your name? 9/10 for the 1st. I believe I rated your 2nd sig awhile back.
Sweet sig. What is that stuff? It looks better than real in your sig, lol. Alot of detail on the grime-stuff. The text matches with everything. GJ! 10/10
I believed I already commented on your Jade Empire sig once b4 so... I really like the Wolverine sig. He blends perfectly with the bg. He also remains a strong focal point within the sig itself. GJ! 9.7/10
9/10 Very cool sig, only thing bad is I can't see all the brushing because that cape of Ed's is HUGE, and the text blending. Perfect on everything else, great job.
9/10 great on everything except the text dont like it that much and the positioning is pretty bad too.