I give the one on the left 6/10 but only because i'm not keen on the style. The one on the right i give 9/10 because ts very eyecacthing and seems to fit together well.
Uhm i like the userbars but the pop-out sig rweall sucks, no dpeth. Zou havent done anything with the render and there isnt even a name on it :S, border sucks too, 4/10.
1. 8/10 Just think the bg could've had matching colours to the hunter. I like this one the most out of the 3. 2. 7/10 Think it needs a 3rd colour and maybe a tad more vibrant 3. 6/10 looks cool, just dunno if the colours match well.