ecks 8.5/10 for both, excellent smudges, but the tan spot to the right of the head on the first is weird and the text in the bottom right on the second kinda killed em a little :S
eeekkk... the text kills it... looks like a pixel stretch dunno if you wanted it that way tho... 6.5/10
re5spoilerman 6.3/10(bg loosk good but work on the text) Ecks 1st: 7.8/10 2nd: 7.8/10(like the simplcity of the smudge)
You think so? i dunno to tell u the truth i thought it was bad ... I dunno but alot of ppl seem to like it heh was my first sig :}
Your font is whored, and you could have done more with the render, also, your pixel font is fked up. but, nonetheless.... Your sigs arent bad. 8/10
The first signature is beautiful, but the font doesn't suit it. My feelings are similar in regards to the second as well. 1) 9/10 2) 8/10