They both look different. Can't really judge anything on those because the bg's aren't very complexed. All tho that golden bg fits with Gek Rates: 3,4 - 5,3.
Freakin hot,.. 1st 9.5/10, I love the feel and what you did with the text. 2nd 9/10, i love how you creativly put your name on this render.
5.5/10 too much contrast 6/10 simple, but it actually looks like night, with the brushing you did is the last one 1 sig? if it is, 9/10, awsome concept, having the two opposite colors and one guy and one chick , it looks awsome. if that was your unique approach than my suggestion is to make the lady bigger so the faces match up
both 8.5/10 i like them a lot you are really good at those sigs that actually look painted, its realy nice thanks for the comments on mine, lol, who wants to join the geox fan club, lol
First: The bright blue, is like, overwhelming, and the lack of a render makes it look empty to me.. 6.5/10 Second:8/10
Okay, your first sig just has a bunch of tech brushes that are withing the top 25 downloaed at deviant art. nothing special there and megaman and his lightsaber?? are a bit pixely. You second I have nothing to say about 2/10 1/10